TL;DR
Turn quiet afternoons into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
More than 1,000 medical professionals, including about 700 physicians, signed a letter defending Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed’s status as a physician. The response followed Republican candidate Mike Rogers’ debate remarks questioning whether El-Sayed is a real doctor because he does not practice clinical medicine in Michigan.
More than 1,000 medical professionals, including about 700 physicians, have signed a letter defending Abdul El-Sayed’s status as a physician after Republican Senate candidate Mike Rogers questioned his credentials during a debate. The signatories argue that El-Sayed’s public-health work is a medical career, even though he does not practice as a treating physician in Michigan.
The letter, released Tuesday and organized by the nonprofit Committee to Protect Health Care, says El-Sayed earned a medical degree and chose to focus on public health. It describes that work as extending medicine’s reach from individual patients to whole communities. The group says its mission is to advocate for quality, affordable health care.
At an earlier debate between the candidates, Rogers said El-Sayed was “not really a doctor” and argued that he could not legally treat a patient who came to his office. Fox News host Sean Hannity made a similar assertion at a Republican town hall in Saint Clair Shores on Monday, saying El-Sayed calls himself a physician but is not one. Those remarks focused on his current clinical practice rather than disputing that he earned a medical degree.
El-Sayed’s campaign points to the American Medical Association’s definition, which describes a physician as someone who has received an MD, DO or equivalent degree after completing the required medical-school course of study. The source report says El-Sayed earned his medical degree from Columbia University. He also holds a doctorate in philosophy from Oxford University, where he studied as a Rhodes Scholar, and has held senior public-health roles in Michigan.
Why the Credential Dispute Matters
The disagreement concerns both the meaning of the word “physician” and the relevance of public-health leadership to a Senate campaign. Voters may distinguish between having a medical degree and currently diagnosing or treating patients. The letter’s signatories contend that El-Sayed’s work in government health departments is a form of medicine with broad effects, while Rogers’ remarks emphasize the absence of a local clinical practice.
The dispute also puts health policy and professional credentials into the campaign debate. The doctors’ letter links El-Sayed’s public-health record to his stated positions on prescription-drug costs, hospital consolidation, medical debt, reproductive health care, and federal health programs. The letter’s claims about his record and agenda are advocacy statements from supporters; the source report does not independently assess their results or compare the candidates’ health proposals.
Popular right now
Vitamix Propel Series 750 Professional-Grade Blender, 4 Programs, Black
Vitamix 5200 Professional-Grade Blender, 64 oz. Container, Black
Samsung 85-Inch QN70H Neo QLED 4K Smart TV (2026)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
El-Sayed’s Medical and Public-Health Career
According to his campaign website and LinkedIn profile, El-Sayed studied biology and political science at the University of Michigan, earned an MD from Columbia, and completed a DPhil at Oxford. He served as executive director of the Detroit Health Department and as director of the Wayne County Department of Health, Human, and Veterans Services.
The signatories say that, as Detroit’s health officer, El-Sayed rebuilt a department they describe as weakened by long-term disinvestment, expanded access in underserved neighborhoods, and led responses to public-health emergencies. Those descriptions appear in the letter supporting him. Its signatories’ full names were withheld for privacy and safety; only a first initial and the first three letters of each surname were included.
“Not really a doctor … Matter of fact, if somebody came into his office and he tried to treat that patient, he’d go to jail.”
— Mike Rogers, at the candidates’ first debate
Clinical Practice Versus Public Health
The dispute does not establish whether El-Sayed currently holds an active license to practice medicine in Michigan or whether he sees patients in a clinical setting. The source report says he does not practice medicine in the state, but does not provide details about his licensure status, specialty training, or current clinical work. It also does not include a response from Rogers addressing the doctors’ letter or the AMA definition cited by El-Sayed’s campaign.
The letter’s signatories are not fully identified, and the source report does not independently verify each signer’s credentials. The number of supporters is reported as more than 1,000 medical professionals, including 700 physicians; the report does not provide a complete public list of names.
The Debate’s Next Campaign Test
The source report does not identify a scheduled response from Rogers, a further statement from the Committee to Protect Health Care, or a specific next event focused on the credential dispute. The issue may continue to surface as the Michigan Senate campaign proceeds, particularly in discussions of health policy and El-Sayed’s qualifications. Voters can expect the competing arguments to remain distinct: Rogers has questioned whether El-Sayed should be described as a physician because he does not treat patients in Michigan, while El-Sayed’s supporters point to his medical degree and public-health leadership.
Further clarity would come from more information about El-Sayed’s current licensure and clinical practice, as well as any detailed response from Rogers or independent professional records. For now, the reported development is the letter’s public defense of El-Sayed, not a new finding about his license or a change to his campaign’s health-care positions.
Key Questions
What prompted doctors to defend Abdul El-Sayed?
The letter followed remarks by Republican Senate candidate Mike Rogers at a debate, where he said El-Sayed was “not really a doctor.” Fox News host Sean Hannity made a similar claim at a Republican town hall, according to the report.
How many medical professionals signed the letter?
The report says more than 1,000 medical professionals signed it, including about 700 physicians. The signatories’ full names were not published; the letter used a first initial and the first three letters of each surname.
What medical qualifications does El-Sayed have?
According to his campaign website and LinkedIn profile, El-Sayed earned a medical degree from Columbia University and a doctorate in philosophy from Oxford University. He has also led public-health agencies in Detroit and Wayne County.
Is El-Sayed currently practicing medicine in Michigan?
The source report says he does not practice medicine in the state, but it does not specify his current license status or whether he treats patients elsewhere. Those details remain unclear in the material provided.
Source: rss
